The FIA's Leclerc ban shows F1 still fears scrutiny
Pulling a veteran reporter's credentials over a column may be defensible on tone, but doing it without notice or a clear process looks like retaliation, not governance.
AI-generated image
Can a sport that sells itself as the pinnacle of global competition really afford to punish a writer for what he thinks of a driver? The FIA just did, and the way it did it tells us more than the insult that set it off.
Here is what happened. As Reuters reports, the FIA revoked Daily Mail reporter Jonathan McEvoy's credentials for the Las Vegas, Qatar and Abu Dhabi grands prix. The trigger was a Nov. 4 opinion column in which he called Charles Leclerc a "sneaky little bastard," after the opening-lap clash with Lewis Hamilton in Mexico City. The Daily Mail answered by boycotting the final three races. The FIA said the column "fell short of the standards of professionalism expected" and that its guidelines allow it to revoke credentials without notice.
The insult was crude. The remedy was the problem
Let's be fair to the FIA. The phrase was coarse, and no one is obliged to defend it as great prose. A governing body can reasonably expect accredited media to meet some standard of conduct. If McEvoy had been warned, heard out and sanctioned through a published process, we would be having a smaller argument.
That is not what has been reported. Part of the FIA's defense is that it can pull a pass without notice. That is a statement of power, not of procedure. A rule that lets an organization remove a critic at will, with no public threshold that we have seen, is not a professionalism standard. In our view it is a leash.
And the target matters. This was an opinion column, which is the genre built to be sharp and unfair to the powerful. The Society of Editors argued that withdrawing accreditation over published criticism threatens independent sports journalism. We think that is the right framing. Whether the language was tasteless is an editorial question for the Daily Mail and its readers. Whether the FIA should be the judge of it is a different one.
"They can send someone else" is a weak defense
The FIA stressed that the ban doesn't stop the Daily Mail from sending another reporter. Technically true, and beside the point. The message to every other accredited writer is clear: the person, not the paper, pays. McEvoy has covered F1 for more than two decades. Removing a veteran for the final three races is a chilling effect even if the seat in the media center is refilled.
There is also the murky part. McEvoy suggested in a later column that Ferrari team principal Fred Vasseur prompted the decision, but a Ferrari source told The Athletic that Vasseur hadn't lodged a complaint. That is unresolved, and we shouldn't treat either version as established. But the fact that we are guessing who triggered the ban is itself the indictment. Without a transparent process, rumor fills the vacuum, and every team and driver becomes a suspect.
What F1 should do now
First, publish the criteria. If conduct in opinion writing can cost you a credential, say what crosses the line, who decides, and how a journalist can respond before the sanction, not after.
Second, separate the complaint from the verdict. If a team or driver objects to coverage, that should be a documented request reviewed by someone independent of the commercial interests of the championship.
Third, confirm the terms publicly. McEvoy says he was told his accreditation would be reinstated next season, but the FIA hasn't publicly confirmed it. A ban with unconfirmed terms is the opposite of accountability.
Some will say the Daily Mail boycott is theater, and perhaps it partly is. A paper can enjoy a good press-freedom fight. Still, the paper is right on the essential point. F1 has spent years courting audiences with access and personality. It can't also treat harsh judgment of its stars as a disciplinary matter.
Our verdict: sanction the manners if you must, but do it by rule, in the open, and proportionately. Until the FIA shows that, this will read as a governing body protecting a brand from criticism. Leclerc, a driver paid to take heat, doesn't need that protection. Neither does the sport.
No topics yet: start the first one.
More stories
Mercedes' title is real, but Antonelli's wet Sunday was a warning
Mercedes sealed the constructors' crown in São Paulo while its new world champion spun from the lead, and that wet Sunday says more about Kimi Antonelli's rain lessons than the trophy.
Interlagos is safe until 2035, but the fans must get the upgrades
São Paulo kept its Formula 1 race through 2035, but "significant investments" only matter if they fix the track and fan experience, not just premium hospitality.
Alan Jones didn't need his hand held, and F1 misses that
The 1980 champion, dead at 80, gave Williams its first title as a blunt, self-reliant racer. His story is a quiet indictment of how polished modern F1 has become.
Haas got the right rookie for Brazil, but handled Ocon the wrong way
Putting Rafael Câmara in the car at Interlagos makes sense on merit and on story. Refusing to explain why Esteban Ocon was removed is the part that should worry people.



