Zidane's first loss is no crisis, but the Mbappé question is real
France's 3-1 defeat in Milan is a normal stumble for a rebuilding team. The harder test for Zidane comes when Mbappé is back and he has to decide who the team is built around.
AI-generated image
Can a team lose its first match under a legend and still be fine? Yes. Can it keep ignoring the one question that will define the whole project? That's harder. France's 3-1 loss to Italy at San Siro is the first, and it is mostly noise. How Zinédine Zidane handles Kylian Mbappé is the signal.
As The Guardian reports, Michael Olise put France ahead after 10 minutes, helped by a Gianluigi Donnarumma error. Pio Esposito then scored twice and Davide Frattesi once, and Italy won 3-1 to go top of the group. It was Zidane's first defeat as France coach, after a first camp of three wins and a draw. France is second, behind Italy on goal difference, and goes through to the Nations League quarterfinals with a draw against Turkey on Sunday in Bordeaux.
This was a normal stumble for a rebuilding team
The case for calm is strong. Radio France notes that 11 French players were in the infirmary, Mbappé among them. Zidane called up a lot of young players, and Rabiot, wearing the armband for the first time, pointed to that inexperience. 20 Minutes says France had 65% possession and twice as many completed passes as Italy. Both Barcola and Cherki hit the post.
We buy Zidane's line that this is part of the learning, with reservations. A young group coming apart after the second goal, as Zidane himself described it, is what young groups tend to do, and nobody should build a narrative on one night in Milan.
The reservations are about the details. Zidane's defense of Malo Gusto, "we can't say he had a bad game", will age badly if the right-back slot keeps leaking. Le Parisien, as relayed by Le Figaro, called this France "too tender", and the full-back area looks like the real construction site. Protecting players in public is fine. Pretending a problem isn't one is a different thing.
The Mbappé question is not about one hamstring
This is where we part ways with the "nothing alarming" chorus. Mbappé missed the match with hamstring pain. Zidane's public line was mild: he hopes Mbappé will be there Sunday, "it's what was planned".
Even so, the story has legs for a structural reason. 20 Minutes makes the sharpest point of the week: people talk far less about "a lack of luck" when Mbappé plays. Without him, Barcola played as a false nine and France created chances. With him, we suspect the team is a different animal, and Zidane has not yet had to say what that animal looks like.
Our view: the honeymoon is over, and that's healthy. The first camp let everyone avoid hard choices because the results covered them. Now Zidane has to answer three things. Is Mbappé the fixed point, with everyone else arranged around him? Does the young, possession-heavy group with Olise, Doué and Cherki work with or without him? And who defends when the ball is lost? Italy answered the last one in the second half.
Sunday should be judged on the press and the duels, not the scoreline
Don't judge the result against Turkey alone. A draw gets France through, and a comfortable win with Mbappé back would prove little. Watch instead how the team presses, how many duels it wins, and whether the full-backs stop being the story. Watch also whether Zidane's message about Mbappé stays this relaxed if the player's fitness becomes a recurring topic.
Milan was a warning, not a crisis
A coach with Zidane's standing can afford one defeat and a polite chat about learning. He can't afford a vague hierarchy. If the next camp still has no clear answer on who is the center of the team and who covers the defensive work, then the Mbappé question will stop being a side story. It will be a real problem.
No topics yet: start the first one.
More stories
Raphinha doesn't deserve a cut: Ancelotti owes Brazil clear rules
The Raphinha row says less about one forward's words than about who sets the terms in Brazil's camp. Ancelotti should keep him and spell out minutes and roles.
Lyon's Carlos Vicens hire is a safe bet that needs a plan
Lyon picked a Guardiola-school tactician with a sensible profile. It works only if the board commits to one identity instead of another reset.
LaLiga treated a player's death as a scheduling problem, and the players are right
Postponing only the matches directly touched by Jesús de Miguel's death, while the rest go ahead, tells players their grief fits around the calendar. A fuller pause was the right call.
Lens 1-9 Como is no fluke: French football has a gap problem
The heaviest Champions League defeat ever for a French club says less about one bad night in Bollaert and more about a Ligue 1 that lives off PSG's shadow.



