Motorsport
Sportsfera Newsroom
Motorsport

Verstappen is right: a heartbeat is data, not content

F1's WHOOP deal promises great TV, but Verstappen's refusal shows why drivers' biometric data should stay opt-in, with clear rules about who sees what.

Published
November 19, 2026
Reading time
3 min
Categories
Motorsport

AI-generated image

What is a driver's heartbeat worth to a TV director? Quite a lot, it turns out. What it's worth to the driver is a different question, and Max Verstappen answered it bluntly this week: not for sale.

Ahead of the Las Vegas Grand Prix, Formula 1 announced a partnership with wearables company WHOOP. As Crash.net reports, a number of drivers will wear the company's trackers, and the data will appear on broadcasts in 2027 to show the physical demands of racing. Verstappen said: "I won't be involved." He added that he doesn't use any device, even for training, and that "people don't need to know my heart rate."

The detail that matters most is in the fine print. As AOL's report notes, the data is personal enough, from respiratory rates to sleep patterns, that F1 needs the drivers' permission to broadcast it. The press release itself speaks of insights delivered "in collaboration with the drivers." So this isn't really a rebellion. It's the system working as designed.

The idea is good television, and we shouldn't pretend otherwise

Let's be fair to F1. Fans spend much of a race watching helmets, and anything that makes the human inside the cockpit feel real is welcome. CEO Stefano Domenicali talks about showing what drivers experience "physically and mentally during the most intense moments of a race," and we think that's a legitimate pitch. Heart-rate figures aren't even new in racing: they debuted in Formula 2 in 2023.

Charles Leclerc shows how well this can work. He's a WHOOP ambassador, says "I don't have anything to hide in particular," and notes there is now a device certified by the FIA that he can wear while driving. A willing driver with a story to tell is exactly the content F1 wants.

The problem is that a number isn't a story

George Russell, who said he'd enjoy it as a neutral but is more hesitant as an athlete, made the sharpest point of the week. A 45-year-old's heart rate is probably going to be lower than an 18-year-old's, he noted, and even people of the same age differ. He worries it will create a narrative that is "positive for some" and negative for others. He would empathize, he said, with a driver whose natural heart rate sits 20 beats higher than a rival's.

We think that's the real flaw in the plan. A raw number on screen looks like objective truth, but without context it's a bad measure of nerves, fitness or courage. Viewers will probably read calm as superiority and a spike as weakness. Commentators may build stories on figures that can't carry them. In a sport where reputations are made and sold, that's not a neutral graphic.

Consent has to be real, not just formal

Verstappen's objection is simple: he doesn't like to be tracked, and he doesn't want to show it. He doesn't need a fitness-science argument to justify that. Privacy is reason enough.

Our concern isn't this season. Today, a four-time world champion can say no in a press conference and that's the end of it. The pressure builds later. If the data becomes a selling point, the driver who refuses may start to look like he's hiding something. Teams, sponsors and rookies on the fringe of a seat won't all feel as free to decline as Verstappen does. That's a prediction, not a fact, but it's the one we'd plan around.

So our recommendation is straightforward. Keep participation voluntary, in writing and revocable. Spell out who owns the data and who else can see it beyond the broadcast. Let drivers see the graphics before they air, which the "in collaboration" language suggests is the intent. And give viewers context, not just a number.

Verdict: F1 should keep the idea and drop any assumption that it will become universal. If it's as compelling as Domenicali promises, willing drivers like Leclerc will deliver it. Verstappen's "no" isn't a threat to the format. It's the proof that the format is honest.

Debate topics

No topics yet: start the first one.

More stories